
Pages: 386
Published: 30th July 2024
Genre: Young Adult Thriller
Content Warnings: Child exploitation

For all of Kat’s life, it’s just been her and her mother, Jamie – except for the forty-eight hours when Jamie was married and Kat had a stepbrother, Liam. That all ended in an epic divorce, and Kat and Liam haven’t spoken since.
Now Jamie is a jewel thief trying to go straight, but she has one last job – at billionaire Ross Sutherland’s birthday party. And Kat has figured out a way to tag along. What Kat doesn’t know, though, is that there are two surprise guests at the dazzling Sutherland compound that weekend. The last two people she wants to run into. Liam and his father – a serial scammer who has his sights set on Ross Sutherland’s youngest daughter.
Kat and Liam are on a collision course to disaster, and when a Sutherland dies, they realize they might actually be in the killer’s crosshairs themselves. Somehow Kat and Liam are the new targets, and they can’t trust anyone – except each other.
Or can they? Because if there’s one thing both Kat and Liam know, it’s how to lie. They learned from the best.

This book is absolute unrelenting chaos, and sadly not of the organised kind. We have an enticing premise and there is some real entertainment to be had at times, yet this fails to mask a plot that contains more holes than a sieve and characters who lack nuance, cancelling out much of its enormous potential. What remains is something of a disorganised mess that leaves your head spinning while you try to make sense of it all.
Needless to say, this is really surprising. Karen M McManus’ young adult thrillers to date have generally been fast paced but well structured with some knockout twists. She has written characters bursting with depth and regardless of their motives be they fair or foul, they make you invested in the story and take you along for the ride. For whatever reason, that does not happen here as what at first seems an intriguing mystery full of jeopardy and infiltration descends into silliness and contrivance.
Most of the damage takes place during the second half of the book. Until the halfway mark there is still plenty to hold on to, not least the originality, as this is not your typical heist novel. There are complicated family dynamics at play, and some set ups that are hard to resist and until the murder happens it feels like we are heading somewhere promising. Although we see a few signs of the mayhem that is to come, it is suitably reined in.
The high stakes we see at first take a different direction after the murder and once the initial thrill of being presented with a mystery with a number of suspects passes by, the story becomes far less interesting. What ensues can only be described as a crazy sequence of events where main characters make irrational decisions, a scarcely believable romance plays out with minimal substance, and several candidates to be the killer remain devoid of any development. In fact, you could argue that the book may have worked better without the murder, as it became one extra thing to think about when there were already a lot of ongoing threads.
Some of the more low-key mysteries carried more weight, such as working out what Luke was planning to gain from the Sutherlands and what Annalise was hiding. These provided faint glimmers of hope, but by the time they were resolved late on it was just too messy and convoluted, with further unlikely twists tacked on for good measure. In truth, it was just difficult to remain emotionally connected with the plot by that point.
The reality that Kat is neither a relatable character nor easy to connect with does not help matters much either. It must be said that the book is never slow to point out that she is chaotic and kind of all over the place, but reading from her point of view is just a little overwhelming, and before long you are having to catch your breath. On the bright side, her dysfunctional lifestyle and the power dynamics of her relationship with her mother and Gem were interesting and always carried the hint of something sinister.
Of the two narrators, Liam was without doubt the more likeable. He is unassuming yet shrewd, and his determination to ruin his awful father’s schemes is an easy thing to get on board with. It is a different kind of father/son relationship and one that is well set up, even if the murder becomes an unwelcome distraction. There was also much to enjoy about him and Augustus, and while there is definitely a spark between them, there is the sense that it feels forced, not to mention an air of insta-love.
The setting is not the most original, but it works well for the premise. It is realised in enough detail that you feel very much drawn into the colossal Sutherland household, can more or less see the art that Annalise fawns over, and get a feel for how far removed their wealth is from our world. What McManus does well here is to strike that effective contrast, with Luke being allowed into that sphere whereas Kat and Luke are thrown headfirst into it.
Overall, there are many positive things to highlight about the concept here, but the execution is far from impressive. There are too many moving parts that arrive, fast and furious, all a bit too difficult to take in and amid all that, the plot loses most of its direction and becomes difficult to follow. On their own, the hunt for the diamond and Liam’s attempts to bring Luke down were more than enough to keep us engrossed, but then in comes the murder mystery to add an unnecessary ingredient to the mix. That, in addition to Kat’s wild first person narrative, all leaves you feeling a bit dizzy by the time you get to the end.

I was disappointed with this one. The murder was an unnecessary plot development and it just became too frantic after that. To be honest, it was a relief to get to the end because by then, I was no longer very invested.
My rating: ⭐⭐
